Who Watches the Watchers - Forum for the Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe & Similar Works 20 YEARS! 2004-2024

You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Raw Data on Official Marvel Works » Poster/Pin-Up Type Entries » 12/31/2023 9:50 am

RVcousin
Replies: 407

Go to post

A last one for 2023
Love Unlimited Infinite Comics #54 - Captain America of the Railways -2 pages (Trading Card style)

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 7/31/2023 6:49 am

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

Lonewolf36 wrote:

RVcousin wrote:

Lonewolf36 wrote:

Both have been seen on panel together and both have been X-Men members so i say yes.

Yes but like Old Man Logan/Wolverine or like the Time displaced original 5 ? 😶

No she was hatched on Krakoa when Talon was believed dead. She is not time displaced and more like a clone of a clone. I could be wrong but much like twins i consider them seperate.

Yes, but that was after her joining, when she entered the team, the clone was believed to be the original, like Jean/Phoenix Force, no ? That questions really tourments my mind lol.

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 7/31/2023 3:03 am

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

Lonewolf36 wrote:

Both have been seen on panel together and both have been X-Men members so i say yes.

Yes but like Old Man Logan/Wolverine or like the Time displaced original 5 ? 😶

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 7/30/2023 2:55 am

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

I have a question about the X-Men membership, I Hope one of the OHOTMU writers (and other members of this forum of course) can give me his own point of view : are the young Laura/Wolverine and the old Laura/Talon considered as two différent members ?

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » Handbook and Index Announcements Thread » 4/22/2023 2:01 am

RVcousin
Replies: 8

Go to post

Hello guys,
Something completely forgotten here, but the May 2023 solicitations has announced 5 handbook variant covers, for each issue of the Spider-Man 2099: Dark Genesis Limted Series.
Well, guess what ?
The 4 first issues can be seen online, and here is for you
https://prhcomics.com/book/?isbn=75960620594300116
https://prhcomics.com/book/?isbn=75960620594300216
https://prhcomics.com/book/?isbn=75960620594300316
https://prhcomics.com/book/?isbn=75960620594300416
 

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 2/03/2023 3:00 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

Loki wrote:

I wouldn't disagree, but it's not me, or indeed any of the handbook writers, you need to convince. Feel free to suggest it to Marvel.

what email address should I write to ?

Raw Data on Official Marvel Works » Poster/Pin-Up Type Entries » 1/25/2023 2:00 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 407

Go to post

I have a question :I know there is a thread dedicated to the trading cards, but what about when the trading cards are reprinted (with their datas) as extras inside a TPB published by Marvel ?
Don't they deserve to appear here ?
 

Raw Data on Official Marvel Works » OHOTMU Sightings Outside the Handbooks - Current Version » 1/16/2023 11:40 am

RVcousin
Replies: 201

Go to post

skippcomet wrote:

Did the Back to School TPB come out in 2013?  Because that's the only one that comes up when I look it up on Amazon.

Yes, it's this one.

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 1/15/2023 1:18 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

The Infinity Comics from Marvel Unlimited could be a good place for new handbooks, what do you think ?

Raw Data on Official Marvel Works » OHOTMU Sightings Outside the Handbooks - Current Version » 1/15/2023 11:13 am

RVcousin
Replies: 201

Go to post

Hello guys,
Big update today with 4 new entries (in real handbook style) :

X-MEN LEGACY TBP : BACK TO SCHOOL
Exodus 1
Mimic 2
Omega 1

EDGE OF SPIDER-VERSE #4 (2022)
Pete Spiderman 3/4
 

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Update '89 Omnibus Has Some Interesting Info In Its Preview » 9/11/2022 12:11 am

RVcousin
Replies: 15

Go to post

I have checked all entries listes on this page and I found them all, but I haven't seen Forbush Man and the Moon Knight Helicopters

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Update '89 Omnibus Has Some Interesting Info In Its Preview » 9/05/2022 9:40 am

RVcousin
Replies: 15

Go to post

Andy E. Nystrom wrote:

Apologies but I think we'd better not: the pages say "Copyrighted Material" so we might get in trouble if we take a screen capture, and it won't let me select text. The Look Inside option seems to be only in the US (.com) version and not France, Canada etc. If you're being redirected to your home country see if you can set things to visit the US version specifically. I can tell you that the Scroll Bar if you click on Look Inside is very tiny and hard to see, It took me a bit of time to find it. So it might be there but hard to spot.
 

Don't be sorry Andy, it's OK and I have found the solution : it wasn't workig on my cell phone, on my computer it worked.
I have made an analysis from the content page of the profiles published outside of the Handbooks and I have some notes :
Forbush Man from Marvel Age #45 is missing
The Pitt (from NewUniverse) is apparently 2 page, but in it was only 1 in its previous edition
Forbush Man from Marvel Age #45 is missing
I guess the Punisher's Battle Van is from Punisher Armory #1
Forbush Man from Marvel Age #45 is missing

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Update '89 Omnibus Has Some Interesting Info In Its Preview » 9/04/2022 12:58 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 15

Go to post

Andy E. Nystrom wrote:

According to the Contents in the Amazon preview, the New Universe profiles will be included.
 

I apparently have the same problem as mal32, I juste have the cover in the preview : I don't know if it is because I am in France or because I am trying with my celle phone.
Can somebody send me the new pages from the preview ?

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Update '89 Omnibus Has Some Interesting Info In Its Preview » 8/29/2022 1:15 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 15

Go to post

"an extensive collection of profiles, schematics and updates originally published outside the Handbooks!"
Andy guesses ?
The NewUniverse ones ?

Raw Data on Official Marvel Works » Poster/Pin-Up Type Entries » 10/24/2021 10:23 am

RVcousin
Replies: 407

Go to post

Secrets of the Uncanny X-Men (January 2019) :
History of the Horsemen (2 pages)

Raw Data on Official Marvel Works » Sagas » 10/24/2021 10:16 am

RVcousin
Replies: 44

Go to post

Hello guys,
Secrets of the Uncanny X-Men has the following (2 pages each) :
Legion Quest Saga
Age of Apocalypse Saga
Age of X Saga
X-Man Saga

Thanks to mal32 for his help on this one

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 6/17/2021 1:07 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

Loki wrote:

RVcousin wrote:

Curious news in the July sollicitations : Sinister War #1 & 2, and Amazing Spider-Man #70 & 71 have all four a Handbook Variant Cover.
What is it ?

News to me. At a guess, they might do the cover art either with the character in a handbook-suitable pose, or even do handbook entries for a character on the cover.

I have found the first 2 covers : it's real 1page Handbook, Doc Ock for ASM#70 and (Lady) Electro for Sinister War #1.
https://mobile.twitter.com/IsraelSilvaArt/status/1402296441738076166/photo/1
https://twitter.com/IsraelSilvaArt/status/1405244834617696264/photo/2

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 5/02/2021 6:54 am

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

Pinball_Lizard wrote:

Time for a couple more about my favorite subject: obscure mutants! The Secrets Behind the X-Men blog mentions yet another '90s mutant whose story arc was apparently canceled, a mutant aide to the notoriously mutophobic Senator Kelly who appeared in UXM 299, 322-23, and XM 51, and then vanished without a trace. Does anyone here know anything more about this character or what direction he was supposed to be taken in?

According to the Deadpool Ranks and Fool Handbook, it's Noah Dubois from Landau, Luckman & Lake

General Information/Discussion on Official Marvel Works » The Official Handbooks General Q&A Thread » 4/22/2021 8:13 am

RVcousin
Replies: 148

Go to post

Curious news in the July sollicitations : Sinister War #1 & 2, and Amazing Spider-Man #70 & 71 have all four a Handbook Variant Cover.
What is it ?

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Handbook announcement - X of Swords Handbook » 1/13/2021 1:44 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 103

Go to post

In Captain Britain (Elizabeth Braddock)'s affiliations, there is the Cable's X-Force missing.
Which brings me to another question : if there was a new X-Force entry, is the team in that 2014 X-Force series, as well as the Cable & X-Force and the 2018 X-Force series the same team than the Cable's Founded X-Force or would it be another teams ?
 

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Handbook announcement - X of Swords Handbook » 12/22/2020 10:51 am

RVcousin
Replies: 103

Go to post

Thank you very very much for all this answers.
I have one last remark about the JGS employees : according to the OHOTMU X-Men 2005, the School Faculty is an Official Sub-Team.

Whatever, thank you very much for your work and your answers.

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Handbook announcement - X of Swords Handbook » 11/30/2020 11:45 am

RVcousin
Replies: 103

Go to post

I have a question for a potential update and that could answer almost every other questions : are all the mutants fighting alongside Jean in X of Swords Destruction, full X-Men members ?

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Handbook announcement - X of Swords Handbook » 10/17/2020 12:23 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 103

Go to post

Rayeye wrote:

Totally agree with you, RVcousin!
 

Thank you Rayeye.
I have noticed another missing ad-hoc X-Men team : all the mutants assembled by Beast in Uncanny X-Men #9 and 10 (2018) to face Nate Grey. They were all considered as X-Men according to Beast.

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Handbook announcement - X of Swords Handbook » 10/17/2020 3:01 am

RVcousin
Replies: 103

Go to post

Loki wrote:

We're in the middle of proofing for King in Black handbook (and some other, non-handbook stuff we've been asked to check over) right now, so I will see about getting answers to the queries above, but it won't be immediately. As such, please feel free to bump the posts to remind me if I've not got back to you in the next week or two.

We have waited 10 years for this Handbook, so don't worry 😉. It's already very nice to have this Handbook and an answer one day.
Good work for the next Handbook and if you need help, I am here.

Individual Official Marvel Handbook, Guidebook, and Files Book Discussion » Handbook announcement - X of Swords Handbook » 10/16/2020 2:27 pm

RVcousin
Replies: 103

Go to post

Hello guys,
First of all and most importantly, thank you, thank you, thank you. 10 years of waiting for an updated roster and 5 years for a X-themed Handbook, I really hope, it's the last time we will have to wait so longly.

It is now my turn to have a lot of questions about the roster :
First of all, what makes a team official, sub-group or unofficial ?
Why is the Red Team considered as an official team, while the Blue team and the London team are only considered as sub-groups and that Magneto's Uncanny X-Men, Havok's Astonishing X-Men and Cyclops's Revolutionary team are not even considered as sub-groups.
Same qestion goes for the following ad-hocs groups, all named X-Men :
1) the First X-Men (from the limited series of that same name)
2) Utopia's Protection Team (all said as X-Men by Cyclops during Second Coming in New Mutants (2009) #14
3) Dead X-Men (from the Chaos War X-Men Limited Series)
4) Jean Grey School Protection X-Men (considered as X-Men by Kitty Pryde in Wolverine & X-Men #14, like Warrior X said earlier today)
5) In Phoenix Resurrection #2, there is X-Men (according to Kitty Pryde), separated in 5 sub-groups (black, silver, gold, yellow and blue)

About the memberships :
1) Lucid is in, as an honorary member, and I'm very happy for that, but why is she officially a member and not Fiz, Deadpool and Energizer, also "honorary members" ?
2) Kid Apocalypse became the X-Men leader during Axis
3) why is Anole still an X-Men-in-Training, since he has graduated in Wolverine & the X-Men #42
4) Alchemy was considered as an X-Man by Cyclops during Death of X (as mentioned by Rayeye)
5) For Krakoa (Hellfire Club's spawn), in Wolverine & the X-Men #3, he asked if he can join the X-Men
6) About Fantomex & EVA, I am agree with you, but apparently the SHIELD isn't according to SHIELD (2014) #1, where Agent Coulson lists the former members of the X-Men and mention Fantomex & EVA.
7) What about more recent Krakoan additions : young Cable (X-Men #1 and 2), Pyro (Aller

Board footera

 

Powered by Boardhost. Create a Free Forum


*****HAPPY TWENTIETH ANNIVERSARY EVERYBODY!!! 2004-2024*****