Offline

Those are more or less correct. List started. A few clarifications/nitpicks (not impacting the results).
To expanded on rule 1, counterparts are we've seen are certainly possible. I've tried to avoid multiple images of the same version of a character. Where things get tricky is that cast changes often denote a new continuity but not always (The Doctor being a prime example where multiple actors across two Doctor Who series and spinoffs have played the same version of a character). And in many cases, continuity might not have been something the filmmakers concerned themselves with and thus even if they're still alive wouldn't be sable to say if two actors were playing the same or different versions of a character.
Jonathan Chase never used the name Manimal in-story to my recollection.
The show Thermoman was on was called My Hero.
The live action segments of Hero High characters were all from Kid Super Power Hour with Shazam!
Offline

I folded the expanded version of the different versions rule into the top post and added a note that no real world "superheroes" such as Captain Sticky are in the collage. Every character in the collage, at least as depicted is fictional, though at least one character is (while heavily changed) based on someone who many believe really existed.
Offline

3 Tim Avery (Son of the Mask)
Offline

4 Eric Draven (The Crow)
Offline

8 John Hancock (Hancock)
Offline

13 Handi-Man (In Living Color)
Offline

18 D.C. Collins (The Fantastic World of D.C. Collins)
Offline

28 Tonto (The Legend of the Lone Ranger)
Offline

40 Lamont Cranston (Alec Baldwin's The Shadow)
Offline

62 Adam Kane (Mutant X)
Offline

67 Don Diego Vega (Douglas Fairbanks's The Mark of Zorro)
Offline

74 Peyton Westlake (Darkman)
Offline

79 Mr. Furious (Mystery Men)
Offline

111 Harry Griswold (Sgt. Kabukiman N.Y.P.D.)
Offline

124 Kato (The Green Hornet TV series)
Offline

53 Kato (Seth Rogen's The Green Hornet)
Offline

146 Stanley Ipkiss (The Mask)
Offline

149 Steve Austin (The Six Million Dollar Man)
Offline

155 David Dunn (Unbreakable)
Offline

154 Darryl Walker (Blankman)
Offline

170 Tonto (2013 The Lone Ranger)
Offline
zuckyd1 wrote:
40 Lamont Cranston (Alec Baldwin's The Shadow)
You know it's 2020 when the first thing you think upon seeing the Shadow is "the mask is meant to cover your nose, idiot!"
Offline

184 Barb Wire (Barb Wire)
Offline

192 Claire Bennet (Heroes)
Offline

219 Kit Walker (1996 The Phantom)
Offline

223 Blue Raja (Mystery Men)
Offline

229 Hiro Nakamura (Heroes)
Offline

242 Tonto (The Lone Ranger TV series)
Offline

257 Weevil (The Specials)
Offline

112 Amok (The Specials)